Overview

Section 1
Section 2
Section 3

Section 4

- Supervision
- Committees
- Institution
- Members
- Membership
- Criteria
- Post Approval
- Monitoring
- Reporting
- Summary
- Case Study 5

Section 5

Conclusion

 

Section 4 - Supervision of Research

Ethics Committees: Criteria for Review and Approval

In order to approve a research project, the Ethics Committee must examine the proposed research thoroughly. At a minimum, the Ethics Committee should address six core issues:
  • scientific design and conduct of the study. The Ethics Committee should consider the design of the research to the extent that it impacts the safety of the participants.

    - Are procedures consistent with appropriate research design? 
    - Is the researcher qualified to conduct the research? 

    It is recommended that the research be reviewed by a scientific review committee prior to Ethics Committee submission. The scientific committee reviews the technical or scientific aspects of the study. 

  • recruitment of research participants. The Ethics Committee should examine the materials and methods by which participants will be recruited.

    - Are the recruitment methods appropriate for the research  
      setting and the subject population?
    - Are there appropriate safeguards in place to protect vulnerable 
      populations?

  • community considerations. The research should address a local need or problem and must be designed with an understanding of the community in which a study will take place. The Ethics Committee must assess the impact of the research on the community.

    - How will the community benefit from the research? 
    - How will community members be included in the design of the 
      study? 

  • care and protection of research participants. The Ethics Committee must examine the impact of the research on the participants.

    - Are adequate measures in place to provide for the well-being of 
      the participant during and, if appropriate, after the study? 
    - How is the study being monitored to ensure the safety of 
      research participants?

  • informed consent. All codes and guidelines require individual informed consent.

    - Are participants adequately informed about the study, the 
      voluntary nature of their participation, and their right to end their 
      participation at any time? 
    - How is informed consent documented?

  • confidentiality issues. The Ethics Committee must review the steps taken by the research team to protect the confidentiality of participants. In some research, the greatest risk could well be a breach of that confidentiality.

    - Are adequate measures in place to protect confidentiality?
    - Will participants be at risk if confidentiality is broken?

Only when all these questions have been answered should the Ethics Committee grant approval

Back

     

Next