Case Study 1:
Respect for Persons

Case Study 2: Beneficence
and Justice

Case Study 3:
Informed Consent

Case Study 4:
Responsibility
in Research

Case Study 5:
EC Considerations

Case Study 6:
Negative Media Coverage

Case Study 7:
Research with Minors

Case Study 8:
Conflict of Interest

Answer Key

 

 

 

Case Study 8: Conflict of Interest

An urban church-run health center is a popular alternative for many people who complain about the poor services and lack of confidentiality in the public-run clinics. As a researcher investigating the effects of a new post-test HIV counseling and case management program, the church health center seems like a perfect site. The well-trained staff of the health center is interested in your research and has past experience implementing similar research with other diseases. The center is already the preferred HIV-testing site in the city.

Upon further discussions with the health center staff, you learn that they are not willing to distribute condoms to post-test clients, even those who test positive for HIV. Although your study does not require condoms to be distributed, you are alarmed that the center would refuse to distribute condoms to HIV-positive clients, thus putting their partners at risk of HIV.

Questions: (Click on the questions to reveal possible answers.)

  1. Do you continue to include this health center in your study?

  2. Are there effective alternatives to providing condoms to infected participants?

  3. The trial does not depend upon the provision of condoms and could still be conducted. Do you have a moral obligation to the participants?