FHI Logo
    Search fhi.org
pixel
  Infinite Menus, Copyright 2006, OpenCube Inc. All Rights Reserved.
pixel pixel
Doc Cover

Programs

Final Report for the
AIDSCAP Program in Senegal
August 1993 to October 1997

Email this to a friend

Contribute Now Sign up for E-news Help families recover in storm-devastated Haiti

This report comprehensively summarizes the FHI/AIDSCAP program in Senegal (1993-1997). The report includes a discussion of accomplishments, outcomes, implementation and management issues, as well as a series of lessons learned and recommendations.

Table of Contents

Executive Summary

I. Country Program Description

A. Introduction

B. Country Context

C. Accomplishments and Outcomes

D. Implementation and Management Issues (See Below)

E. Non-Subproject Highlights (See Below)

II. Lessons Learned and Recommendations

III. Subproject Highlights

IV. Attachments

Glossary of Acronyms

I. Country Program Description (continued)

D. Implementation and Management Issues

Introduction

In 1992, an AIDSCAP implementation team conducted an evaluation in Senegal to assess the situation and to design an HIV/AIDS prevention and control project that could address the unmet needs of the Programme National de Lutte Contre le SIDA (PNLS). In addition to USAID, the World Health Organization (WHO), the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA), the European Union (EU) and the French Cooperation were pledging support for the PNLS. WHO was primarily assisting with administrative support, sentinel surveillance, testing, and technical assistance in the development of a medium term plan (MTP), however indicated it would not be able to continue financing surveillance, and was therefore seeking a replacement donor. The French Cooperation pledged to strengthen the screening of blood products nationwide and CIDA pledged a two year program focusing on BCC activities and training in the regions of Diourbel, Kolda and Tambacounda. The EU was strengthening selected STI clinics outside Dakar.

Responding to the Government of Senegal's (GOS) wish to decentralize the AIDS control program, the AIDSCAP project was directed towards four of the ten Senegalese regions with more than 60 percent of the population: Dakar, Thies, Kaolack and Ziguinchor. The following major components of the national STI/AIDS control program were subsequently supported by AIDSCAP:

  • Behavior change communication (BCC)
  • Strengthening case management of STIs
  • Distribution of condoms nationwide (not just in the AIDSCAP intervention regions)

While these components were considered crucial, other components such as policy dialogue, support to the PNLS in strategic planning, grant support to national and international NGOs as part of capacity building, behavioral and operations research, and evaluation (including support for sentinel surveillance) were considered as complementary and important components of the PNLS program requiring support.

The three major components targeted high-risk populations, such as commercial sex workers (CSWs), other women at risk with multiple partners, men at risk, such as male partners of CSWs, men in the workplace, long distance drivers, and the military. Youth were targeted, both those in and out of school due to their nature of high-risk behaviors. While the focus was on urban and to a limited extent rural populations, it was found that more attention needed to be paid to the serious problem of internal/external migration for both men and women, and the particular risks for those who stayed at home and were therefore exposed to returning infected spouses. Women appeared to be particularly disenfranchised, and the notion that only commercial sex workers were "high risk" was reevaluated in light of new assessments. The recession and the devaluation of the CFA franc further weakened the rather fragile economic fabric facing women. In addition to CSWs, women at risk were migratory domestic workers looking for work, single divorced mothers with children, co-spouses in polygamous marriages, and uninformed spouses exposed to the virus by returning husbands.

Implementation

Process

Implementation of the AIDSCAP/Senegal project began in July 1993 with the arrival of the Resident Advisor in Dakar. Initial project activities focused on the renovation of office space, recruitment of office personnel, and other administrative activities related to project functioning according to Senegalese regulations. Rapid contacts were made with bilateral, multilateral and international organizations and agencies working in AIDS. This was followed by initial field visits to the project regions (with the exception of Ziguinchor) to present the project and discuss issues with regional personnel.

In terms of subproject activities, initial work concentrated on the development of workplans for all components of the project. A subagreement for epidemiological surveillance, inherited from the Global Program on AIDS (GPA), was finalized and identification of STI pilot areas and definition of a strategy were completed.

Important strides were made in the NGO grant component, with the development of a grants brochure outlining criteria necessary for grant proposals. Once the criteria was specified, a two-day workshop was conducted to present the initiative to the NGO community. Following this workshop, work focused on involving two NGO consortiums in the planning and management of this component: Conseil National des ONG Africains pour le Développement (CONGAD) and the International Council of AIDS Service Organization (ICASO).

Formulation of BCC activities began with the arrival of the expatriate IEC officer and recruitment of the IEC national expert. As the primary emphasis of the project was behavior change communication, initial work of the experts concentrated on determining what was currently occurring in the field. Work then shifted to the development of the specific plans of action for each target group.

Establishing Interventions

By the end of the first year of the AIDSCAP project considerable advances had occurred in all program areas. Despite major constraints beyond the control of the Senegal program, such as the blockage of funds for a period of eight months, creative ways were explored to continue activities. The STI component completed a baseline survey in all intervention regions for pilot STI sites. This was immediately followed by the signing of two subagreements outlining the objectives and outcomes of the STI interventions in the selected sites with the PNLS and the Association Des Postes de Santé Catholiques au Sénégal (APSPCS). Relating to the STI interventions, a Targeted Intervention Research (TIR) focusing on treatment seeking practices of patients with STIs also began. Initial analysis of data on general health beliefs showed new information that was considered valuable in explaining why the population was not as concerned as expected about STIs.

Behavior change communication (BCC) focused primarily on training. Training sessions were conducted for health personnel, social workers, school teachers, youth organizers, and women's organizations. AIDSCAP, in collaboration with the PNLS, conducted training in the form of training of trainers (TOT) workshops and sessions on peer education techniques. Subprojects were developed through Letters of Agreement (LOA) and subagreements, in collaboration with the AIDSCAP regional office and headquarters, targeting men in the workplace, university students, women, commercial sex workers, women of low literacy levels, out of school youth, and the general population (through mass media). The development of educational materials for targeted high-risk groups was also undertaken.

AIDSCAP/Senegal focused on the logistics aspects of the condom promotion and distribution component, taking into consideration the quantities agreed upon with the USAID Mission and the PNLS. The PNLS condom storage space in the national warehouse was renovated with security fencing and locks, electrical repairs and pallets to stock condom cases. A new quarterly distribution system was established to deliver condoms to the 10 regions of Senegal for specific institutions as determined by the PNLS.

One of the main emphasis of the AIDSCAP project was to encourage NGOs to include AIDS prevention behavior change communication activities in their work. In Senegal, as in other countries, it was recognized that the government could not accomplish this task alone. During the period that AIDSCAP/Senegal was developing its implementation strategy, there was only one NGO (ICASO-Senegal) regrouping approximately a dozen other NGOs, whose work concentrated on HIV/AIDS. One larger NGO, CONGAD, a collective of more than 85 Senegalese and foreign NGOs, had the major role of coordinating the work of all NGOs in Senegal. CONGAD worked to create an exchange of information to avoid unnecessary duplication between NGOs, to strengthen NGO/government relations and to offer services to its members such as the provision of technical assistance, the production of two network periodicals and the running of a business center. Against this backdrop, AIDSCAP/Senegal initiated an intervention with African Consultants International (ACI) to network closely with both groups in order to widely publicize the new AIDS training possibilities for NGOs.

This intervention with ACI focused its attention in two main areas of support: 1) training NGOs in AIDS prevention activities; and 2) encouraging policy dialogue. With regard to training, it was determined that if NGOs were to play a role in AIDS prevention and control they must have in-house expertise on AIDS. A series of TOT workshops were held for NGOs interested in conducting AIDS prevention work. These seminars targeted primarily non-health, development NGOs, although NGOs working in health were not excluded. It was anticipated that at the end of their training, participants would understand the causes, modes of transmission, prevention measures and socioeconomic implications of AIDS. NGOs would also be informed of the types of funding available for HIV/AIDS projects. In response to the AIDSCAP Women's Initiative, ACI made an effort to ensure that fifty percent of the trainers or participants at each workshop would be representing NGOs which had a primary focus on women's issues, and/or were run by women. It was hoped that by specifically targeting NGOs concerned with women's issues, AIDSCAP Senegal would receive proposals that were gender oriented and culturally sensitive, and which would explore new avenues to reach a broader target audience (i.e. monogamous women at risk, women in the workplace, female adolescents, separated/divorced women and other unmarried women).

In order to encourage a favorable environment for conducting AIDS activities, a study involving individual interventions and focus group discussions with religious, political and community leaders was also included in the subproject with ACI. The results of this study became a starting point of discussions with the regional opinion leaders, religious leaders (both Muslim and Christian), and members of parliament, through seminars, symposia and conferences.

By the end of the project, AIDSCAP/Senegal had successfully put into place 25 major interventions through subagreements and Letters of Agreement and 34 short-term activities with local associations through the rapid response fund mechanism.

Constraints

  • The conversion of AIDSCAP from a cooperative agreement to a contract slowed down the commencement of implementation by eight months. The Country Office had to reformulate workplans and modify budgets to fit the new contractual format.
  • The devaluation of the Franc CFA declared at the beginning of 1994 was disastrous in the sense that the prices of basic materials and services increased dramatically. In anticipation of this devaluation the government imposed a 12 percent tax on all imported commodities including those falling under the category of "duty free". USAID condoms destined for free distribution for the AIDS program were received on time, however their delivery was delayed while the issue of the 12 percent tax was being resolved.
  • USAID policy on the non-purchase of drugs or drug-related substances and the lengthy process for obtaining a waiver caused a delay in the startup of activities relating to STI operations research and sentinel surveillance.
  • USAID policy prohibiting the payment of salaries to government personnel involved with any of its projects hindered the implementation of five subprojects with the GOS. Although training was offered as a motivation, it was not perceived as such. In specialized areas AIDSCAP/Senegal resorted, with authorization from USAID, to acquiring services of consultants on a short term basis.
  • For a period of two years, all travel to AIDSCAP's region of Ziguinchor was prohibited for security reasons due to the civil strife in that region.

Management

By the beginning of 1994, AIDSCAP/Senegal had been allocated office space consisting of six rooms, within the locality of Centre d'Hygiène de Médina. The office space was provided by the GOS as part of their contribution to the AIDSCAP project, in conformity with the provision contained in the bilateral agreement signed between USAID/Senegal and the GOS.

  1. Staffing
    The number of staff members required to run the AIDSCAP/Senegal program was outlined in Senegal's Delivery Order # 1. It consisted of a Resident Advisor (Expatriate), IEC Officer (Expatriate), IEC Officer (National), Accountant, Administrative Assistant, Executive Secretary, Secretary/Receptionist, Cleaner and two Drivers. All of these staff positions were filled by the beginning of 1994. Two additional staff members were recruited towards the end of the project: an Assistant Accountant and an IEC Assistant.
  2. Finance
    Due to USAID mission's policy prohibiting government agencies which are involved in implementing project activities from operating their own accounts, AIDSCAP/Senegal set up a system for handling these funds. The system consisted of a special government account to facilitate transfers from AIDSCAP/HQ, procedures for requesting these funds by the Government agencies, and the preparation of Government agencies monthly financial reports by the AIDSCAP Country Office Accountant. In addition to this account, the office managed an account for operational expenses, as well as BCC activities run from the office, rapid response funds, condom promotion, and evaluation.

Constraints

  • The office space provided by the GOS was too small. All staff members, except the Resident Advisor, were required to share offices of inadequate sizes.
  • As the program moved into full implementation, it became clear that additional staff was required for both subproject monitoring and financial management.
  • The departure of the Resident Advisor after two years of program implementation and operation, and subsequent 5 month vacancy of this post, and the departure of the IEC Officer (expatriate) created a gap in the management of the office, as well as in the implementation of subprojects.
  • The operation of a special government account added to the workload of the accountant. Although the recruitment of an accounting assistant was subsequently authorized by the USAID Mission, the workload still remained heavy due to the large number of subprojects being implemented.

Capacity Building (Management)

Capacity building was one of the major goals of the AIDSCAP program. The AIDSCAP/Senegal office determined that capacity building was not only applicable to local implementing agencies, but also for the AIDSCAP team itself. Thus, a one day training course in AIDS education and prevention was conducted for all members of the AIDSCAP staff by African Consultants International (ACI), prior to the startup of implementation of the program.

The goals of this training were: to help team members protect themselves and their families from infection of HIV/AIDS; to increase the commitment of each team member to the goals of the AIDSCAP project; and to give all team members the basic skills necessary to participate in the process of gathering and disseminating information related to the epidemic, the prevention of the spread of HIV and the care and support of those infected.

In terms of technical skills, the national IEC Officer attended a training course in program management in Santa Cruz, California. The same IEC Officer together with the Assistant IEC Officer attended a one-week BCC workshop held in Kenya, regrouping all IEC Officers of AIDSCAP's countries in the Africa region. The two accountants also benefited from in-house training on FHI's accounting procedures, and the assistant accountant attended a one week workshop in Kenya for all AIDSCAP's accountants in the Africa region. AIDSCAP/Senegal also organized in-house computer training for the National IEC Officer, the two secretaries and the two accountants.

As keeping abreast of current information on HIV/AIDS was also considered a priority, the National IEC Officer attended the African International Conference on HIV/AIDS in Kampala, Uganda in 1995 and the Resident Advisor attended the International HIV/AIDS Conference in Vancouver in 1997.

E. Non-Subproject Highlights

Following a restructuring of the internal division for the prevention of AIDS of the Ministry of Education, a plan of action was elaborated with the following objectives:

  1. Sensitize students and education personnel of all levels of AIDS prevention issues;
  2. Organize information and training days for teachers, supervisors and heads of educational facilities.
  3. Develop educational materials and supports for teachers and students;
  4. Supervise, monitor and coordinate the activities of different partners targeting schools.

AIDSCAP supported the training of professors of natural science and home economics, the establishment of AIDS prevention centers in 25 schools, and the organization of BCC activities and training of supervisors of literacy programs. In addition, 2,500 educational brochures were produced for literacy classes in 6 local languages, a training module was developed for students, 15 educational facilities were supported in organizing AIDS prevention activities and technical assistance was given for the restructuring of the internal AIDS division of the Ministry of Education.

Support was also given to the PNLS for the organization of special events -- World AIDS Day, Women and AIDS Week, and Youth AIDS Week. Each region and district elaborated a one-week program of activities and community mobilization.

Ninety small associations of youth, women and men received financial, material or technical support to organize BCC activities. One hundred and twenty activities, such as conferences, radio shows, theater presentations, discussions and debates, were held reaching 13,106 people. Other BCC activities were held with the following populations:

  • 100 women leaders of women's groups
  • 67 health union representatives and leaders of transport workers/drivers
  • 40 company heads and doctors

A conference on Women for the Prevention of AIDS was organized with 20 representatives from NGOs with the objectives of informing the NGOs of the AIDSCAP initiative for women, identifying the different priority target groups for AIDSCAP, and elaborating a list of priority interventions for each target group. As a result of this conference, the following target groups were identified: adolescents aged 13-20 in the informal sector; young girls aged 8-12; managers of bars and small restaurants ("gargottes"); women's associations.

Two information campaigns were carried out with the development of 40 billboards, 300 posters for buses, and 1000 stickers. In addition, local radio stations covered 13 hours of special events and round table discussions, and 2 television commercial were developed -- one which ran during the World Cup and another 20 second spot which ran two times per week for one month.

Finally, two workshops were held for 36 NGOs to discuss the diversity of interventions and reexamine the relations between partners, identify factors which influence the functioning and results of projects, share evaluation results, and develop priority strategies and actions for the sustainability of AIDS prevention programs. These two workshops resulted in the following recommendations:

  1. AIDSCAP should ensure partners have the same understanding of project objectives and desired results at project startup to avoid duplication of efforts.
  2. Organizations must have the means to continue activities if sustainability is to be achieved.
  3. An effective system of monitoring should be established.
  4. Activities in different regions should be coordinated in order to avoid the dispersion of means.
  5. Avoid target groups which are too large or dispersed which may exceed the capabilities of the NGOs.
  6. Review the policy of free condom distribution to avoid creating a demand for which adequate means are not available to satisfy.
  7. Review the length of peer educator training to ensure adequate time is given to achieve the goals of the training.
  8. Reinforce targeted interventions.
  9. Encourage a larger participation of women in AIDS prevention activities, particularly in rural settings.
  10. Although BCC should remain a priority intervention strategy, interpersonal communication should also be emphasized.
  11. To achieve greater autonomy among associations and NGOs, fundraising activities should be initiated among local organizations