This report covers the FHI AIDS Control and Prevention (AIDSCAP) Project (1991-1997). Volume 2 contains brief summaries of each FHI/AIDSCAP country program or activity.
Table of Contents
Volume 2
Introduction
Africa
Major Countries
- Cameroon
- Ethiopia
- Kenya
- Nigeria
- Rwanda
- Senegal
- South Africa
- Tanzania
- Zimbabwe
Associate Countries
- Côte d'Ivoire
- Lesotho
- Mali
- Mozambique
- Niger
- West Africa
- Zambia
Asia
Major Countries
- India
- Indonesia
- Nepal
- Thailand
Associate Countries
- Bangladesh
- Egypt
- Mongolia
- Morocco
- Philippine
- Sri Lanka
Areas of Affinity
- Indian Subcontinent
- Indonesia/Philippines
- South Pacific Island Nations
- Thai/Cambodia/ Vietnam
- Thai/Lao PDR/Burma
Latin America/ Caribbean
Major Countries (See Below)
- Brazil
- Dominican Republic
- Haiti
- Honduras
- Jamaica
Associate Countries
- Bolivia
- Colombia
- Costa Rica
- Ecuador
- El Salvador
- Guatemala
- Nicaragua
- Peru
- Regional Activities
Volume 1
Latin America/Caribbean, Major Countries: Brazil
Epidemiology
Brazil has the largest HIV/AIDS epidemic in South America. The country is home to 50 percent of the population of South America but has 75 percent of the region's AIDS cases. The first AIDS case was reported to the Ministry of Health (MOH) in 1982; several earlier cases were retrospectively identified. By May 1997, 110,845 AIDS cases had been reported to the Pan American Health Organization. While many countries have higher per capita AIDS incidences, only the United States has reported more cumulative AIDS cases. The HIV/AIDS epidemic in Brazil is concentrated in highly populated urban areas, such as São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Pôrto Alegre, Santos, and Belo Horizonte.
Men who have sex with men (MWM) have experienced high rates of infection since the beginning of the Brazilian epidemic. In 1994, HIV seroprevalence among MWM was 24 percent in Rio de Janeiro and 28 percent in Pôrto Alegre. While seroprevalence remains high among MWM, the proportion of AIDS cases occurring among this population decreased from 50 percent in 1988 to 23 percent in 1996. The proportion of cases due to heterosexual transmission increased from 5 percent in 1988 to 31 percent in 1996. Consequently, the male to female case ratio has decreased from 9:1 in 1987 to 3:1 in 1996.
Sentinel surveillance has documented high HIV prevalence among other at-risk populations. Studies completed in the early 1990s show that 6 percent of commercial sex workers (CSWs) serving upper-income clients in São Paulo were infected with HIV. Among CSWs serving low-income clients, seroprevalence ranged from 12 percent in São Paulo to 27 percent in Santos, a major port. Sexually transmitted infection (STI) clinic attendees also have high rates of infection. Seroprevalence among STI patients was 15 percent in São Paulo and 23 percent in Rio de Janeiro. Studies of STI patients in smaller cities have found lower rates of infection, ranging from 1 percent in Aracaju to 9 percent in Salvador. Injecting drug use also accounts for a substantial proportion of HIV infections in Brazil. Approximately 19 percent of cumulative AIDS cases have occurred among injecting drug users (IDUs). Sentinel surveillance has found HIV prevalence as high as 65 percent among IDUs in several cities.
While seroprevalence is higher among those groups considered at-risk, rates of HIV infection are increasing among the general population. Seroprevalence among pregnant women, often used as a proxy for sero- prevalence among the general population, ranges from 0 percent in rural states to nearly 3 percent in the city of Pôrto Alegre. As the number of infected women has increased, the proportion of AIDS cases due to vertical transmission has also increased, from 0.5 percent in 1985 to more than 3 percent in 1996. The MOH estimates an HIV seroprevalence of 1 percent among men and women aged 15 to 49 in the states of São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro .
In Brazil, the only STIs subject to epidemiologic surveillance are congenital syphilis and AIDS. As a result, little is known about the prevalence of other STIs, such as gonorrhea, chlamydia, or primary and secondary syphilis. As in many settings, asymptomatic infection among women and self-treatment by men contribute to high STI prevalence in Brazil. Studies on STIs in CSWs found point prevalence of 66 percent in São Paulo and 69 percent in Santos. These rates are worrisome because they indicate high-risk behavior among CSWs and because concomitant STI infection can greatly increase HIV transmissibility.
Country Overview
Brazil is the largest and most populous country in Latin America and the fifth largest and most populous country in the world. Seventy-seven percent of Brazil's population of 160 million live in urban areas. The cities São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro rank third and ninth, respectively, among the world's largest cities. Since independence, Brazil has often experienced political instability and has been subject to several military dictatorships. Although Brazil has relatively low rates of unemployment, the disparity between the upper and lower socioeconomic groups is among the largest in the world.
Cultural factors influencing the HIV/AIDS epidemic include the extreme alienation of the gay community, which often leads to low self-esteem, fatalistic attitudes about HIV/AIDS, and sexual risk taking among this population; traditional gender roles that often limit communication about STI/HIV prevention and impede women's ability to negotiate condom use; the acceptance of multiple sexual partners for men; abuse of alcohol and other drugs; rapid urbanization; and the marginalization of Brazil's poor. In addition, economic necessity forces many women and girls into commercial sex work.
USAID identified Brazil as a priority country for HIV/AIDS prevention in 1992, after completion of the AIDSCOM and AIDSTECH projects. The goal of the AIDSCAP program was to reduce the incidence of sexually transmitted HIV infection in Brazil. AIDSCAP/Brazil identified three strategies to achieve this goal:
- reduce sexually transmitted infection prevalence by improving STI clinical services, expanding services to new clinics, and increasing use of new and existing STI clinics by creating a referral system.
- reduce high-risk sexual behavior among the target groups through behavior change communication (BCC).
- increase condom use by improving accessibility, availability, and affordability of condoms.
AIDSCAP/Brazil targeted male and female CSWs, MWM, STI patients and their partners, men away from home , women, and youth. The states of São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro were the geographic focus of the interventions; however, during the final year of the project, AIDSCAP expanded its interventions into the impoverished northeast, which has a rapidly growing HIV/AIDS epidemic.
Accomplishments
Strengthening STI Services
The STI component of AIDSCAP/Brazil employed several strategies to decrease STI prevalence. Recognizing the importance of surveillance to STI control efforts, AIDSCAP supported the development of a health information system in Santos and Rio de Janeiro. Second, AIDSCAP worked to improve STI diagnosis and treatment by training clinic staff in the syndromic management of STI. AIDSCAP/Brazil translated an STI manual entitled Control of Sexually Transmitted Diseases: A Handbook for the Design and Management of Programs, and published nearly 10,000 copies in Portuguese. This manual is intended for use in Portuguese-speaking Africa as well as in Brazil. In addition, AIDSCAP supported the development of a newsletter on STIs for health professionals.
Approximately 2,000 health care professionals from Rio de Janeiro, Santos, Ceará, and Bahia were trained in syndromic management and gender sensitivity. AIDSCAP also supported the decentralization of STI services and the creation of new clinics. In Santos, the number of STI treatment facilities increased from 1 to 22 over the life of the project. STI treatment is now available at every public health clinic in the city. BCC campaigns emphasized appropriate treatment-seeking behaviors among target audiences, increasing demand for STI services. Finally, AIDSCAP worked with the MOH to improve STI drug logistics.
Condom Promotion and Distribution
The condom promotion component of AIDSCAP/Brazil exceeded its goals for distribution and sales. During the life of the AIDSCAP program, 14.8 million condoms were given away free-of-charge and 72 million were sold through condom social marketing programs. AIDSCAP/Brazil contracted with DKT do Brazil to develop and market a new brand of condom, called Prudence. Prudence condoms were advertised on television, radio, and billboards and promoted by AIDSCAP's other implementing agencies. This affordably priced and well-advertised condom created competition in the condom market, which forced other condom manufacturers to aggressively market condoms. As a result, annual condom consumption increased from 50 million to 200 million between 1992 and 1996. Prudence is now the third largest brand in Brazil.
Behavior Change Communication
The BCC component of the AIDSCAP/Brazil was characterized by innovative approaches to educational interventions. BCC activities used a variety of media, such as videos, brochures, posters, radio programs, and street theater to communicate messages about STI/HIV/AIDS prevention to the target audiences. Behavior change messages included partner reduction, consistent and correct condom use, and appropriate and timely treatment for suspected STIs. During the life of the project more than 16,000 people were trained and more than 1.3 million people were educated. In addition, 7.8 million educational materials were distributed.
Capacity Building
AIDSCAP's provision of technical assistance and resources to implementing agencies engaged in HIV prevention in Brazil resulted in significant organizational and institutional development. Specifically, AIDSCAP noted the following trends in a study of organizational development conducted in December 1996:
- Increased demand for technical services from AIDSCAP implementing agencies.
- Increased use of monitoring and evaluation information for project planning and implementation.
- More effective financial management and systems in implementing agencies.
- Improved coalitions, involving stakeholders and counterpart organizations, for program implementation and policy development.
Conclusions about the sustainability of initiatives is premature. However, the institutionalization of AIDSCAP's strategies and techniques, the scaling up of AIDSCAP pilot projects and reproduction and adaptation of its materials, and the improved funding environment for HIV/AIDS prevention in terms of both public and private sector support are promising for future interventions. Encouragingly, Associação Saúde da Família (ASF), the NGO that served as the AIDSCAP office in Brazil, has received funding from the Brazilian government, U.S.-based private foundations, and the private sector to continue its prevention activities. ASF has implemented a high-profile HIV/AIDS fund-raising campaign targeting the Brazilian general population.
Key Outcome Data
In order to evaluate the effectiveness of AIDSCAP interventions, surveys on STI/HIV/AIDS knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and practices (KABP) were conducted with several target groups before and after the interventions. In the preintervention surveys, awareness of HIV/AIDS was nearly universal among all target groups, but knowledge of specific means of prevention and perception of personal risk was much lower. Qualitative data from in-depth interviews and focus group discussions were also collected.
Postintervention surveys showed improved KABP among the target groups. Among MWM in Rio, knowledge that condoms can prevent HIV transmission increased from 71 to 93 percent. While few MWM reported reducing their number of partners, many reported increased condom use or avoiding penetrative sex with casual partners. The proportion of MWM reporting consistent condom use increased from 60 percent in 1993 to 89 percent in 1995. Among CSWs, knowledge that HIV can be transmitted through vaginal intercourse increased from 79 to 95 percent, and reported consistent condom use with clients increased from 57 percent in 1991 to 93 percent in 1997. More than 96 percent of CSWs interviewed had condoms with them at the time of the interview. Reported condom use with regular partners also increased substantially, from 12 to 22 percent, though it remains low. Many CSWs reported that alcohol use sometimes interfered with their ability to enforce condom use with clients.
Adolescents reported fewer misconceptions about HIV/AIDS in the postintervention surveys. Awareness of the asymptomatic nature of HIV infection increased from 76 to 90 percent among this population, although knowledge that other STIs can be asymptomatic was much lower. Reported consistent condom use increased from 25 to 40 percent among adolescent females and from 40 to 77 percent among males in this age group. This is a significant increase over control areas: the most recent Demographic and Health Survey notes that only 20 percent of Brazilian women aged 15 to 19 use condoms. Men away from home reported a decrease in sex with casual partners, from 20 to 14 percent, and increased condom use with casual partners.
Special Features
The AIDSCAP/Brazil program was characterized by innovative approaches to potential constraints. A position paper written by DKT do Brazil is credited with the Brazilian president's decision to decree a yearlong tax holiday on the 60 percent duty levied on imported condoms. The duty was reimposed after one year, but at a much lower rate of 10 percent.
AIDSCAP/Brazil leveraged approximately $4 million in private sector investments, which greatly increased the sustainability of project activities. DKT International provided nearly $2 million worth of condoms to condom promotion projects. A number of companies, including Levi-Strauss, Unilever, publicity agencies, and several fashion magazines, provided in-kind contributions that furthered prevention activities. With support from the Brazilian postal service and the MOH, an AIDS awareness postal stamp was created showing the red ribbon symbol superimposed on a condom. A T-shirt, "Wear for a Cure," also raised awareness of HIV/AIDS among the general population. The popular women's magazine Claudia collaborated with AIDSCAP by publishing a series of monthly articles about HIV/AIDS. This contribution allowed HIV prevention messages to reach Claudia's 700,000 readers.
Formative research and program evaluation were also key components of the AIDSCAP program in Brazil. An important study on the acceptability of the female condom concluded that this method increased the chances of successful condom negotiation and safer sex, and offered an alternative contraceptive option for women wishing to prevent pregnancy. Study participants were motivated not only to use the female condoms, which were provided free of charge during the study, but also to purchase the device after the study's completion.
Implementing Partners
- Associação Brasileira Interdisciplinary de AIDS (ABIA)
- Appropriate Health Resources and Technologies Action Group Ltd. (AHRTAG)
- Association for the Prevention and Treatment of AIDS (APTA)
- Center for AIDS Prevention Studies, University of California at San Francisco (CAPS)
- Childhope
- DKT do Brazil/Population Services International (PSI)
- Implementing Agency for Cooperation and Training (IMPACT)
- Instituto de Estudos da Religião (ISER)
- John Snow, Inc. (JSI)
- Organização de Apio ao Portador do Virus da AIDS (OASIS)
- State University of New York (SUNY)
- União Brasileira Contra as DST
- Women, Children, Citizenship & Health
Latin America/Caribbean, Major Countries: Dominican Republic
Epidemiology
HIV/AIDS has been well established in the Dominican Republic since the mid-1980s. Between 1983 and 1996, 3,289 cases of AIDS were reported to the national AIDS control program, Programa de Control de Enfermedades de Transmisión Sexual y SIDA (PROCETS). PROCETS estimates the actual number of AIDS cases to be as much as 70 percent higher. While men who have sex with men (MWM) have experienced high rates of infection, heterosexual contact is the most common mode of transmission in the country, accounting for more than 80 percent of infections. Seroprevalence among pregnant women, often a harbinger of an epidemic in the general population, has increased steadily from 0.7 percent in 1991 to 2.2 percent in 1996. Certain areas of the country have been more affected than others; in 1996, the Puerto Plata region reported HIV seroprevalence of 8 percent among women seeking antenatal care. High rates of HIV infection have also been found among those groups traditionally considered at-risk, such as MWM (12 percent), commercial sex workers (CSWs) (7 percent), and sexually transmitted infection (STI) clinic attendees (7 percent ) The male to female case ratio has dropped from 7:1 in 1984 to 2:1 in 1996, suggesting an increasingly heterosexual epidemic.
Country Overview
Located in the western Caribbean, Hispaniola is the second-largest island in the Antilles. The Dominican Republic (DR) occupies the eastern two-thirds of the island, while Haiti occupies the remainder. The country has 8.2 million inhabitants, most of whom are of mixed Spanish and African ancestry, although a minority predominantly of European descent comprises the country's political and economic elite. Tourism has become increasingly important to the Dominican economy, and agricultural production is reliant on Haitian labor, as large numbers of Dominicans move from rural to urban areas and to the United States.
Several structural factors contribute to the spread of HIV/AIDS in the Dominican Republic. Urbanization, Haitian immigration, and seasonal migration to the United States have led to increased sexual risk taking and increased contact with high-prevalence populations. The marginalization of poor neighborhoods has also increased sexual risk taking, especially among youth. Alcohol abuse also plays an important role. Limited economic opportunities for women lead many to engage in commercial sex, and social and religious barriers to condom use hinder the widespread adoption of safer sex practice.
The Dominican Republic became an AIDSCAP associate country in 1992, following completion of the AIDSTECH and AIDSCOM projects. Epidemiological projections that year estimated that by the year 2000 as many as 5 percent of the adult population, or 300,000 persons, would be infected with HIV. In 1992, USAID changed the status of the Dominican Republic from an associate to a priority country, greatly increasing both funding and technical support for HIV/AIDS prevention.
The goal of the AIDSCAP program was to reduce the incidence of sexually transmitted HIV infection in the Dominican Republic. AIDSCAP/DR identified three strategies to achieve this goal:
- To decrease the prevalence of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) through improved diagnosis, treatment, and prevention.
- To increase condom use among target groups and the general population by expanding access, availability, and acceptability.
- To reduce sexual risk taking among target groups through behavior change communication (BCC).
AIDSCAP/DR targeted MWM, CSWs, adolescents and young adults, people in the workplace, and family planning clients as groups at risk of HIV infection.
Accomplishments
The AIDSCAP/DR program provided financial support and technical assistance to 15 nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). These NGOs conducted behavioral research, implemented educational interventions, promoted condom use, and worked to improve STI services. Support of governmental agencies, including the national laboratory and PROCETS, strengthened epidemiological surveillance, improved the government's ability to respond to the HIV/AIDS epidemic, and led to the promulgation of a national AIDS law.
AIDSCAP/DR implemented BCC subprojects ranging from person-to-person educational interventions to a mass media campaign targeting youth that aired on Dominican television and radio. These subprojects trained 21,000 people, educated nearly 930,000, and distributed approximately 1.5 million educational materials. The mass media campaign aired nearly 500,000 TV and radio spots.
The STI component of the AIDSCAP program worked to decrease the prevalence of STIs by upgrading clinic and laboratory facilities, improving drug logistics, and developing STI treatment protocols. Recognizing that the Dominican health system had limited resources, AIDSCAP/DR developed an algorithm for the syndromic management of STIs. Evaluation showed the algorithm to be effective, and 854 service providers were trained in syndromic management.
Six implementing agencies worked to develop condom distribution networks in the regions where educational interventions had been implemented. In an effort to improve quality and increase affordability, AIDSCAP developed and marketed a new condom, called Pantera. During the life of the program, over 2 million Pantera condoms were distributed free-of-charge and 4.6 million were sold.
Key Outcome Data
Evaluation research shows that the AIDSCAP program helped reduce high-risk sexual behavior in the Dominican Republic. During the program, both awareness of HIV and knowledge of how to prevent the infection increased among all the target groups. Men from the general population reported reducing the number of partners, avoiding sex with CSWs, and using condoms more frequently. Both male and female youth in Santo Domingo reported delaying sexual debut and decreasing their involvement in commercial sex. Condom use increased, and self-reported STIs decreased across the target groups. Most significant, HIV seroprevalence appears to have remained stable in most of the sentinel populations.
Over the course of the program, sexual risk taking decreased among both target groups and the general population. In 1992, 73 percent of youth in poor neighborhoods of Santo Domingo reported that they were sexually active; in 1996, only 30 percent reported sexual activity. Among this same population the proportion reporting that they engaged in transactional sex decreased from 27 to 7 percent among males and from 9 to 6 percent among females. In the general population, 85 percent of men and 26 percent of women report having changed their sexual behavior to avoid HIV infection.
Condom use increased significantly during the AIDSCAP program. Condom use at last sexual encounter increased from 80 to 98 percent among brothel-based CSWs and from 38 to 63 percent among MWM. In the Puerto Plata region, the percentage of hotel employees who use condoms during sexual encounters with tourists increased from 86 to 95 percent.
Inconsistent reporting of STIs limits the conclusions that can be made about trends in STI prevalence. However, rates of self-reported STIs have decreased among the target groups. In Puerto Plata, self-reported STIs dropped from 11 to 7 percent among CSWs and from 15 to 1 percent among hotel employees. The proportion of CSWs reporting that brothel owners require regular gynecological exams increased from 89 to 98 percent. Knowledge of STI treatment locations increased strikingly among target groups.
Most significant, HIV seroprevalence appears to be stabilizing in several sentinel populations, including STI clinic attendees, where prevalence has averaged about 7.5 percent since 1992. Preliminary data suggest that the rate of HIV infection declined slightly among pregnant women from 1995 to 1996 -- from 2 to 1.2 percent in Santo Domingo and from 1.2 to 0.3 percent in San Francisco -- although continued surveillance is necessary to confirm this trend. HIV appears to be spreading rapidly in the tourist region of Puerto Plata, where seroprevalence increased among pregnant women from 4.1 percent in 1995 to 7.9 percent in 1996.
Special Features
A highlight of the AIDSCAP/Dominican Republic program was the extraordinary success of its mass media campaign. The campaign received unprecedented private sector support from radio and television stations, which donated more than U.S. $9 million worth of free air time to broadcast HIV/AIDS prevention messages. Given the current climate of decreased donor funding, the private sector will be called on to play an increasingly prominent role in HIV/AIDS prevention efforts. The active involvement of the national media in HIV/AIDS prevention is an important example of private sector/NGO collaboration.
Building capacity and sustainability was a key focus of the AIDSCAP/Dominican Republic program. AIDSCAP conducted an institutional development workshop for representatives from NGOs working in HIV/AIDS prevention and worked to develop partnerships between these NGOs, which had previously seen themselves as competing for funding and recognition. As a result of this emphasis on collaboration, several subprojects were implemented by two Dominican NGOs working cooperatively. At the end of AIDSCAP funding, the five central NGOs had developed institutional sustainability plans, and all had secured funding from other donors for additional HIV/AIDS prevention projects.
Implementing Partners
- Agencia Latinoamericana de Expertos en Planificación H. (ALEPH)
- Amigos Siempre Amigos (ASA)
- Coordinadora de Animación Socio Cultural (CASCO)
- Centro de Enfermedades de Transmisión Sexual y SIDA (CETS)
- Centro de Orientación e Investigación Integral (COIN)
- Comité de Vigilancia y Control de SIDA (COVICOSIDA)
- Fundación Cultural y Educativa (FUCES)
- Instituto Dominicano de Desarrollo Integral (IDDI)
- Instituto Nacional de Salud (INSALUD)
- Laboroto Rio de Janeiro Nacional de Salud
- Patronato de Lucha Contra el SIDA (PLUS)
- Programa de Control de Enfermedades de Transmisión Sexual y SIDA (PROCETS)
- Technicmarketing
- University of Washington
Latin America/Caribbean, Major Countries: Haiti
Epidemiology
HIV prevalence in Haiti is estimated to be 10 percent in urban adult populations and 4 percent in rural areas. The female to male ratio of HIV/AIDS-infected persons is close to 1:1. Of all HIV infections reported in the country, 80 percent occur in young adults aged 20 to 44, many of whom contracted the infection during adolescence. The prevalence of non-HIV sexually transmitted infections (STIs) is also high. An AIDSCAP-funded study of 1,000 women attending an urban antenatal clinic in an impoverished area found that 46.9 percent of women in the sample were infected with at least one STI. Overall, STI/HIV/AIDS epidemiology in Haiti parallels high-prevalence patterns found in parts of sub-Saharan Africa.
Country Overview
USAID/Haiti began supporting HIV/AIDS prevention in Haiti in June 1989 through Family Health International's AIDSTECH Project. In April 1991, the USAID project was expanded and renamed Aba SIDA (Haitian Creole for "Down with AIDS"). Shortly after the initiation of the expanded Aba SIDA Project, a military coup deposed Haiti's democratically elected government and ignited a severe political and economic crisis that lasted almost 4 years. Although the United States withdrew development assistance to Haiti in protest of the military government, HIV/AIDS prevention in the private and nongovernmental sector was exempted, allowing for a continuation of Aba SIDA activities. The Aba SIDA Project was the only nationwide response to the HIV/AIDS epidemic during this period. Under a new cooperative agreement with Family Health International (FHI) that began in October 1992, technical assistance responsibility for Aba SIDA was transferred to FHI's AIDSCAP Project. Aba SIDA ended in June 1996.
AIDSCAP/Haiti was designed to respond to an advanced HIV/AIDS epidemic and pronounced prevalence rates for other STIs. Therefore, its target populations were broad: adolescents and sexually active adults. Other behavior change interventions were tailored to meet the particular needs and perspectives of smaller, well-defined target populations, including commercial sex workers and their clients, women and men in the workplace, adolescents in schools and communities, and patients with symptoms of sexually transmitted infections. The communication strategy for targeted interventions was based on a variety of behavior change messages to accommodate individual variability both within and among target audiences.
AIDSCAP/Haiti's behavior change interventions with specific target audiences were multifaceted projects. While behavior change communication (BCC) was the centerpiece of the interventions, distributing condoms, facilitating access to STI care, and engaging the support of influential persons in target communities were also important components.
Accomplishments
Twenty Haitian institutions received technical and financial assistance to conduct key interventions to reduce the sexual transmission of HIV/AIDS and STIs. During the life of AIDSCAP, Haitian communities and grassroots organizations made remarkable progress in raising awareness about STI/HIV/AIDS and encouraging behavior change. More than 800,000 people were educated on how to protect themselves from HIV/AIDS, and more than 400,000 educational materials were distributed. More than 6,000 health workers, nongovernmental organization (NGO) personnel, and community volunteers were trained in the skills needed to sustain HIV/AIDS prevention programs, and more than 16 million condoms were sold or distributed through condom social marketing activities.
Strengthening STI Services
After an elected government was installed in Haiti, national guidelines for STI case management were developed and adopted by the new Haitian Ministry of Health. These national STI management guidelines were disseminated in June 1996 after extensive research, training, and institutional development had built a consensus with public and private sector practitioners on STI diagnosis and treatment. Although no measurement of STI treatment according to the national guidelines was feasible, a measurement of the percentage of clinicians in an AIDSCAP-funded project correctly treating the most common STI syndrome increased from 10 percent in 1993 to 69 percent in 1995.
Policy Dialogue
In addition to the development of national STI policy, other activities were undertaken to improve the policy environment in support of HIV/AIDS prevention. The first forums on women and HIV/AIDS in Haiti were sponsored, and a dialogue was initiated to ensure that women's concerns were addressed in Haiti's new plan of action for HIV/AIDS prevention. AIDSCAP also sponsored a mass media campaign, with special events aimed at increasing the awareness of the public of the HIV/AIDS epidemic and increasing social support of prevention projects.
Improving Care and Management
Through the AIDSCAP AIDS Care and Management Small Grants Initiative, three hospitals in Haiti received financial support to improve hospital and home-based care for AIDS patients and social support for people living with HIV/AIDS and their families, to provide economic assistance to affected families through income-generation activities, and to integrate prevention services into their care activities.
Capacity Building
Evidence of increased managerial and technical capacity of the AIDSCAP/Haiti implementing agencies was documented through a rapid assessment survey and in-depth interviews. Program managers reported increased staff skills in a range of technical areas, including BCC, condom social marketing, evaluation research, and STIs. Improvements in program management were reported in the areas of report writing, financial management, and strategic planning. In addition to improved staff skills, program managers reported improved management systems for finance, monitoring, and evaluation. Finally, all program managers cited improved networking with private and public sector organizations and developing coalitions.
Key Outcome Data
AIDSCAP/Haiti programs led to a significantly increased understanding of HIV/AIDS transmission and prevention methods in both high-risk target populations and the Haitian population in general. Behavioral changes were also reported. Three significant outcomes of the AIDSCAP program, evident from an analysis of baseline and postintervention research in AIDSCAP target audiences, are that the knowledge of HIV/AIDS has substantially increased, personal risk assessment skills have improved, and a high percentage of the population report behavioral change to reduce the risk of HIV/AIDS infection.
Documented Outcomes for the General Population in Haiti
| Aware of the sexual transmission of HIV |
| |
1990 |
1995 |
| 60% |
90% |
| Knew of at least one prevention method |
| |
1990 |
1995 |
| |
95% |
| Unable to assess personal risk for HIV/AIDS |
| |
1990 |
1995 |
| 18% |
1% |
| Knew of condoms |
| |
1990 |
1995 |
| men |
69% |
95% |
| women |
54% |
95% |
| Knew of one or more sources for condoms |
| |
1990 |
1995 |
| |
>90% |
| Ever used condoms |
| |
1990 |
1995 |
| men |
16% |
32% |
| women |
6% |
12% |
Special Features
During the period of the AIDSCAP program, Haiti endured major political and economic crises. A coup d'état in 1991 paralyzed the National AIDS Control Program (NACP). The economy was also severely impaired, and violence was widespread. Donor agencies withdrew their development assistance to Haiti to protest the coup. Through AIDSCAP, however, USAID continued to support NGO-based HIV/AIDS prevention in Haiti. During this time, as the only major HIV/AIDS prevention activity in the country, AIDSCAP assumed many of the responsibilities of the NACP, including coordinating and funding activities, providing technical assistance to specific intervention projects, and conducting high visibility HIV/AIDS awareness and advocacy campaigns. The current level of prevention and control efforts in Haiti is due to USAID's commitment to HIV/AIDS interventions in the country despite the political circumstances, as well as the dedication of AIDSCAP and its NGO partners to carry on despite the upheavals.
Implementing Partners
- Alliance des Femmes Haïtiennes
- Centre de Promotion des Femme Ouvrières
- Centre Haïtien de Service Social
- Centres pour le Développement et la Santé
- Comité d'Action des Jeunes Contre le SIDA
- Grace Children's Hospital
- Groupe de Lutte Anti-SIDA
- Groupe Haïtien d'Etude du Sarcome de Kaposi
- et des Infection Opportunistes
- Haitian Association of Public Health
- Haitian Institute for Community Health
- Hôpital Albert Schweitzer
- Hôpital de Fermathe
- Implementing Agency for Coorperation and
- Training/Inter-Aide
- Institut Haïtien de L'Enfance
- Miraj Productions
- Population Services International/DOBACO
- Producteurs Haïtiens Reunis
- Professional Management Services
- Save the Children
- Volontariat pour le Développement d'Haïti
Latin America/Caribbean, Major Countries: Honduras
Epidemiology
Honduras has the highest AIDS prevalence in Central America. While only 17 percent of the population of Central America lives in Honduras, the country has 48 percent of the region's AIDS cases. By April 1997, 9,376 persons with HIV infection had been registered, although public health authorities estimate that the actual number of cases is 30 to 50 percent higher. Ninety-three percent of cases are a result of sexual transmission. Men who have sex with men (MWM) represent approximately 13 percent of reported cases. Approximately 83 percent of the cases are among heterosexuals, and the ratio of men to women is 1.8:1, although young women are disproportionately overrepresented. The increasing number of infected women has led to increased vertical transmission: children under the age of five now account for 4 percent of cases.
The city of San Pedro Sula is the center of the Honduran HIV/AIDS epidemic. Sentinel surveillance of pregnant women in San Pedro Sula has documented HIV prevalence of up to 4 percent. The capital, Tegucigalpa, has a relatively lower prevalence. While urban areas have the highest rates of infection, every department in the country has reported cases of HIV or AIDS. According to projections made in 1993, AIDS may affect between 10 and 17 percent of adults in San Pedro Sula and between 4 and 12 percent of adults in Tegucigalpa by the year 2000. The largest number of new HIV infections are expected to occur among the 20- to 24-year-old age group.
Country Overview
Honduras borders Nicaragua, El Salvador, and Guatemala, and has coastline on both the Pacific Ocean and the Caribbean Sea. Approximately 90 percent of its population of 4.8 million are Mestizo (a mix of indigenous and Spanish heritage). The remainder of the population is of African, indigenous, or Spanish descent. Honduras is one of the poorest countries in Latin America, and an estimated 40 percent of the population is either unemployed or underemployed. The majority of Hondurans live in rural areas, although rural-to-urban migration has led to high rates of growth in cities such as San Pedro Sula and Tegucigalpa. Many women and youth from rural areas migrate to the garment factories near San Pedro Sula. The country's major exports include bananas and textiles.
Structural factors that fuel the Honduran HIV/AIDS epidemic include poverty and the social disruption caused by civil wars in Central America. Lack of economic opportunities force many women into the commercial sex industry. Alcohol abuse also plays an important role in sexual risk taking.
Following an AIDSCAP-funded socioeconomic impact study, Honduras became an AIDSCAP priority country in 1995. Prior to the AIDSCAP program, there had been a minimal response to the epidemic on the part of both governmental and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs).
The goal of the AIDSCAP program was to reduce the incidence of sexually transmitted HIV infection in Honduras. AIDSCAP/Honduras employed the following four strategies to achieve this goal:
- Reduce sexual risk taking among the target groups through behavior change communication (BCC).
- Decrease the prevalence of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) through improved diagnosis, treatment, and prevention.
- Increase condom use among both target groups and the general population by expanding access to, and availability and acceptability of condoms.
- Strengthen the capacity of Honduran institutions to respond to the HIV/AIDS epidemic with appropriate and effective prevention activities.
AIDSCAP/Honduras targeted commercial sex workers (CSWs) and their clients, MWM, people in the workplace (PWP), and the Garífuna (an ethnic minority) as groups at risk of HIV infection.
Accomplishments
During the 2 years of the program, AIDSCAP/Honduras reached 557,659 Hondurans with HIV/AIDS prevention messages. The program supported BCC interventions among groups with high levels of risk behavior, such as CSWs and MWM. In addition, interventions were conducted among groups who currently have low HIV prevalence but who may be at high risk of acquiring HIV, such as PWP and the Garífuna. The AIDSCAP interventions among PWP and the Garífuna represent the largest-scale HIV/AIDS interventions ever conducted among these populations.
Strengthening STI Services
The AIDSCAP/Honduras program achieved its goal of improving STI diagnosis and treatment services. In a joint collaboration with the Ministry of Health (MOH), the Units for the Integrated Management of STI (UMIETS) were strengthened. AIDSCAP improved STI diagnosis and treatment services by training 306 MOH clinic staff in syndromic management and providing funding to remodel and upgrade clinics. The UMIETS sought to destigmatize STI services by creating a separate clinic for CSWs. NGOs funded by AIDSCAP made STI services more accessible by creating a system for referring individuals suspected of having STI to the UMIETS. In addition, AIDSCAP supported a study on antibiotic-resistant gonorrhea conducted by the MOH and the Institute of Tropical Medicine. The study found that 60 percent of the gonococcal isolates that were tested were resistant to penicillin and 89 percent were resistant to tetracycline. As a result of this study, MOH authorities changed the national protocol for the treatment of gonorrhea and updated the national guidelines for STI management.
Condom Promotion and Distribution
The condom promotion component of AIDSCAP/Honduras surpassed its goals. In an effort to increase condom use in Honduras, the program developed a distribution system in the four health regions where STIs and HIV/AIDS were most prevalent. Central storage centers were created to protect the condoms from excessive heat. Condoms were made available at 756 distribution posts, which included MOH clinics, social security offices, factories, brothels, and bars. In rural areas, condoms were available in the homes of peer educators. By the end of the project, more than 5.7 million condoms had been distributed, surpassing the goal of 4 million. This achievement is particularly impressive because condom promotion activities in Honduras coincided with a mass media campaign against condoms conducted by a group called Pro Life. In addition, the Catholic Church in Honduras rigorously opposed the promotion of condoms.
Capacity Building
Significantly increased capacity among all of AIDSCAP's implementing partners was an important outcome the program's efforts. AIDSCAP worked with a range of NGOs and governmental organizations who had little previous experience in HIV/AIDS prevention and improved their management capacity and accountability by strengthening their administrative and accounting systems. Technical assistance in evaluation techniques, including the design, implementation, and analysis of behavioral data relevant for the design and evaluation of interventions, was provided to every organization.
Organizations reported increased capacity in BCC, conceptual development, and materials design. Another area of technical improvement was in the management of STIs. Physical resources provided to each organization improved the effectiveness of organizational management, communications, and presentations. AIDSCAP also facilitated institutional development through workshops, conferences, and training sessions, which allowed for better networking and the exchange of lessons learned by program managers involved in HIV/AIDS prevention efforts in different target populations throughout Honduras.
Key Outcome Data
At the beginning of the AIDSCAP program, several implementing agencies conducted surveys to assess their target audiences' knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and practices (KABP) with regard to HIV/AIDS. As AIDSCAP did not begin activities in Honduras until 1995, follow-up KABP studies will be conducted in 1999. Several agencies also conducted qualitative research that was used to develop targeted interventions.
Baseline KABP data indicated that while most Hondurans had heard of HIV/AIDS, few knew how to prevent transmission and fewer still were acting on that knowledge. For example, 100 percent of CSWs interviewed had heard of HIV/AIDS, but only 70 percent reported consistent condom use with clients. While 87 percent of MWM reported condom use, few reported condom use in every sexual encounter. Awareness of HIV/AIDS among the general population was much lower. Among men and women in the workplace, only 19 percent of men and 22 percent of women could cite two or more ways to prevent HIV/AIDS infection. More than 76 percent of men reported having sex with partners other than their permanent regular partner, and 8 percent reported having sex with other men. Only 62 percent of men and 20 percent of women reported having ever used a condom. Of those who reported condom use, 11 percent reported using them for every sex act. Only 47 percent of those interviewed knew how to use condoms correctly.
Special Features
One of the successes of AIDSCAP/ Honduras was the design of a protocol for rapid program implementation. The idea behind rapid program implementation was to jump-start national HIV/AIDS prevention efforts by bringing representatives from collaborating agencies together for intensive training. Representatives from 26 public and private sector organizations participated in a week-long training workshop on project design. Ten of these organizations participated in a second workshop that emphasized project development. As a result of this intensive effort, AIDSCAP and its partners were able to complete most of the project subagreements within 2 weeks, and the Honduran HIV/AIDS prevention effort was underway within a month of the initial training workshop.
Implementing Partners
- Asociación de Municipalidades de Honduras (AMHON)
- Centro de Estudios para el Desarrollo y la Participación Social (CEDEPS)
- Comunidad Gay Sampedrana (CGS)
- Centro de Orientación y Capacitación en SIDA (COCSIDA)
- Comunicación y Vida (COMVIDA)
- Fraternidad Sampedrana de Lucha Contra el SIDA (FSLS)
- Instituto Hondureño de Seguridad Social (IHSS)
- Ministry of Health (MOH)
- Institute of Tropical Medicine (ITM)
- Organización de Desarrollo Étnico Comunitario (ODECO)
- Oficina Gubermental de la Mujer (OGM) Programas para el Desarrollo de la Infancia y la Mujer (PRODIM)
Latin America/Caribbean, Major Countries: Jamaica
Epidemiology
The first case of AIDS in Jamaica was diagnosed in 1982, and by 1993 there were more than 500 known cases. One year later, there were more than 800 cases, 64 percent male and 36 percent female, with all parishes reporting incidence. As of December 1996, data showed a total of 2,060 cases. According to the sentinel surveillance data of the Ministry of Health (MOH), the number of individuals infected with HIV is currently estimated to be between 5,000 and 10,000, 80 percent of whom are heterosexual. The majority (59 percent) of AIDS cases occurs in young adults, aged 20 and 39, with 8 percent pediatric cases.
In 1993, HIV prevalence was estimated at 0.1 percent in the general population and 0.3 percent in urban areas, and in 1996 prevalence was an estimated 0.3 and 0.4 percent. Sexually transmitted infection (STI) clinic attendees in Kingston and Montego Bay had a rate of 4 percent in 1994. While HIV prevalence is relatively low in comparison with other Caribbean countries, the large commercial sex industry, high rates of alcohol and drug abuse, the sizable number of migrant laborers, and high rates of STIs indicate the potential for the epidemic to have a devastating impact in Jamaica. Homophobia in Jamaica is a difficult barrier to reaching men who have sex with men (MWM).
Country Overview
Jamaica has a population of approximately 2.5 million persons of primarily African, European, East Indian, and Chinese origin. Nearly half reside in urban areas, with half of these urban residents living in metropolitan Kingston and St. Andrews. Literacy rates are 80 percent for women and 76 percent for men. More than 40 percent of Jamaican households are headed by women. Life expectancy is 69 years for men and 73 years for women. About one-third of the population lives in poverty.
In 1988, USAID/Jamaica expanded upon its previous prevention activities with the implementation of an AIDS/STI prevention and control project, which was designed to address the growth in AIDS cases and the dramatic increase in STIs. In 1992, this project was extended for 4 additional years, as USAID/Washington selected Jamaica as one of the 15 priority countries worldwide to receive technical assistance under the AIDSCAP Project. At that time in Jamaica, the epidemic was not yet believed to be overwhelming and prevention activities were considered to have the potential for significant impact.
The goals of the AIDSCAP program were to
- reduce the rate of sexually transmitted HIV/AIDS.
- decrease STIs through improved diagnosis and treatment.
- increase condom use by expanding and improving access.
- reduce the number of sexual partners through behavior change communication (BCC) among the target groups.
The primary target groups for the program were STI clinic attendees, commercial sex workers (CSWs), adolescents, adults with multiple sex partners, MWM, and people living with HIV/AIDS. Intermediate target groups included policymakers and opinion leaders, medical professionals, and commercial sector retailers. Geographically, the program covered the entire island, with some subprojects focusing on particular target populations and some focusing on urban areas.
Accomplishments
Behavior Change Communication
In the 4 years of the AIDSCAP/Jamaica project, a wide range of print material and mass media communication was produced and distributed to all of the targeted risk groups. To ensure consistency within the campaigns, the MOH communication team formed a BCC team of all AIDSCAP subproject managers that worked to guarantee uniform messages countrywide. A total of 6,017 people were trained and over 760,000 were educated by the Jamaican subprojects. More than 1.3 million copies of program materials were distributed.
Strengthening STI Services
When the program started, Jamaica had a well-developed STI diagnosis and treatment system, including infrastructure in both public and private sectors. Not only were public STI clinics operating, but the country also had national case management guidelines. In addition to reducing HIV transmission, the goal of the national program was to reduce the economic and psychosocial burden of STIs and their complications by decreasing overall morbidity and mortality. As a result of the AIDSCAP/Jamaica program, syphilis screening was decentralized, STI case management was strengthened, private practitioners were trained, and studies on vaginal discharge and genital ulcer disease were conducted.
During the AIDSCAP program, guidelines for STI case management and counseling were revised. Some 2,000 copies were distributed to service providers, including all 13 public STI and 13 antenatal clinics. More than 100 clinics were following manual guidelines by the end of the project. The reporting of clinic data was improved, and a new STI software database was developed and implemented. In addition, more than 500 public and 1,200 private sector health care workers received STI training. The program was also responsible for training and deploying peer counselors in 16 clinics.
Condom Promotion and Distribution
The purpose of the condom component of the AIDSCAP/Jamaica program was to decrease the rate of STI/HIV/AIDS infection by increasing the accessibility of condoms to specific target populations through nontraditional outlets. The goal was increased acceptability of consistent, correct use of condoms by these groups. The primary target populations for this component were young, sexually active adults (aged 15 to 30) and persons with multiple partners, including CSWs and STI clinic attendees. In general, Jamaicans were more likely to use condoms in 1996 than before the AIDSCAP program began. Since 1985, when condom use was estimated at about 2 million per year, annual consumption has increased to more than 10 million. In the past 3 years alone, consumption doubled. AIDSCAP subprojects distributed more than 5.1 million condoms over the life of the project.
Key Outcome Data
Data reported by the MOH at the end of the AIDSCAP program showed that primary and secondary syphilis prevalence decreased from 39 to 23.3 per 100,000. Incidence was down among both men and women. The number of cases of congenital syphilis declined from 62 in 1991 to 19 in 1996. In addition, the public sector reported that 100 percent of STI clinic attendees were treated for syphilis and gonorrhea according to national guidelines. A survey conducted of private sector physicians indicated that an estimated 61 percent were treating STI patients properly.
Evaluation research has shown substantial increases in knowledge and risk prevention behaviors among the majority of the Jamaican population, despite a minority who continue to believe in myths of HIV transmission and continue to engage in high-risk behaviors.
Knowledge levels, already high in 1992, continued to rise as belief in the myths of HIV transmission declined. More than 95 percent of the general population correctly cited two methods of HIV/AIDS prevention in 1996, an increase from 91 percent 4 years earlier. Increased knowledge of HIV/AIDS prevention methods was most striking among 12 to 14 year olds. Only 70 percent of boys and girls could cite two or more prevention methods in 1994, while 96 percent could in 1996.
In terms of modifying risk behaviors to avoid HIV infection, risk reduction strategies varied considerably among men and women and among different age groups. In general, men reported fewer partners and longer relationships, while women reported increased triple partners and condom use.
Adolescent boys reported decreased levels of sexual activity and delayed sexual debut, while younger adult men reported fewer multiple regular and nonregular partnerships. The percentage of boys aged 12 to 14 who became sexually active by age 15 declined from 58 percent in 1994 to 41 percent in 1996. The percentage of men aged 15 to 29 reporting nonregular partnerships declined from 42 to 25 percent. Men aged 20 to 49 dramatically decreased their rate of multiple regular partners as well, from approximately 60 to 30 percent.
Only 37 percent of women reported using condoms during their last sexual intercourse with a nonregular partner in 1992, compared with 73 percent in 1996, with 30 percent reporting every-time use in 1992 compared with 64 percent in 1996.
Special Features
The use of a public relations firm to promote behavior change and leverage media support in Jamaica sets this program apart from other AIDSCAP country programs. The public relations firm worked closely with the MOH's epidemiology unit and nongovernmental organizations to implement subprojects. The coordinated BCC strategy creatively used local culture, music, drama, celebrity endorsements, and humor to communicate safer sex messages to a broad cross section of the island's population. Some of the most successful BCC slogans were, "You can't tell by looking," "Only you can stop AIDS," "Using a condom is the way to live," and "Keep on keepin' it on." The public relations project was able to leverage over U.S. $1 million in sponsorship and in-kind contributions for the program's activities from the private sector and the media.
Implementing Partners
- American National Red Cross (ANRC)
- Association for the Control of Sexually Transmitted Infections (ACOSTRAD)
- Berl Francis and Company, Limited
- Futures Group, Inc.
- Hope Enterprises
- Jamaica AIDS Society (JAS)
- Little People & Teen Players Club
- Medical Association of Jamaica (MAJ)
- Ministry of Health, Epidemiology Unit (EPI Unit)
- Nurse Practitioner Association (NPA)
- Statistical Institute of Jamaica (STATIN)